Let's Be Careful Out There

One of my favorite TV shows from the 80s, or ever really, was “Hill Street Blues.” If you're old enough to remember it, you may recall Sgt. Esterhaus at the end of each day’s briefing sternly but grandfatherly telling all the cops "let's be careful out there." As we all try to figure out how the current “Wall Street Blues” will shake out, I think this is sound advice, particularly for people who have structured settlements or are contemplating entering into structured settlements.

Hysteria and panic are generally bad bases for making financial decisions. All indications are that the backbone of the American insurance industry remains strong and stable. Effective state insurance laws that closely regulate the type and diversity of assets that insurers can hold (that back-up the insurance obligations) are working. Consider for instance the largest and most prominent insurance company, AIG. Headlines scream that AIG is “in trouble” and so forth. Read further and you will see, almost mentioned in passing, that the insurance business units at AIG, particularly the life insurance companies, seem to be sound. The fact that potential buyers are clamoring for AIG’s insurance lines should tell us all something.

The insurance business is unique. In our otherwise generally laissez-faire economy, insurance is excruciatingly and minutely controlled by state regulators. Details concerning what can be sold and to whom, and how payment obligations and risks are planned for and capitalized are all subject to strict rules and review. By all accounts at this point, the system is working, even at AIG.

Some insurers have failed in the past to be sure. But to echo remarks made by Messrs. Darer and Cravenho, these are few and far between. The largest “failure” that I know of is Executive Life of New York (ELNY). In 1991 ELNY was taken over by the State of New York and has been in “rehabilitation” ever since. To date, all policies have been paying as planned. Recent news was made when regulators from New York determined that there might be a shortfall in 12-15 years unless corrective action is taken now. Let me summarize: This “failed” insurer has been able to pay 100% of its obligations for the past 17 years, and while ELNY is likely to need its own bailout/rescue from New York regulators, it appears that individual payees of ELNY structured settlement annuities should fair well in the ultimate resolution of this company. To be sure, the projected shortfall needs to be addressed, and I think it will be, but individual payees should take comfort from this example of a “failure.”

AIG is not only one of the largest insurers, but is one of the largest structured settlement annuity issuers. Structured settlements remain a very viable and useful means of settling personal injury lawsuits, providing long-term financial security for tort victims. Predictable and reliable monthly or yearly tax-free income is a great boon for these former plaintiffs and their families, and all indications are that nothing in this current economic turmoil will diminish those benefits. Structured settlement recipients and their advisors should think twice about trying to “dump” this asset in the face of generally bad economic news. The “best interest” standard given in the federal tax code and in most state transfer laws still applies, and a decision to liquidate all of one’s future structured settlement payments in a factoring transaction because of bad news in the press is probably a bad one. Moreover, liquidating solely because of fear and uncertainty relative to the financial circumstances of AIG or any other annuity issuer would likely not meet the best interest standard required for court approval of a transfer.

However, if a structured settlement recipient does have a real need to sell future payments, structured settlement factoring companies can help. But, in this and all things, “let’s be careful out there.”

If you would like to discuss this or any other matter, please contact me at mbracy@setcap.com. I welcome comments to this and all articles, either here on the blog, or privately to me via email or phone.

Comments

[CHRISTIANJacobs26]

If you want to buy a house, you would have to receive the <a href="http://lowest-rate-loans.com">loans</a>. Moreover, my father commonly takes a college loan, which seems to be the most useful.